Compare HALT
The difference is clear.
Destructive Approach
Advantage
Disadvantage
Incineration
- Mature approach
- Requires temperatures >1800 °F
- EPA intends to prohibit incineration
- Air emissions
Electrochemical Oxidation
- Effective for destruction of long chains
- Produces short chains
- Energy intensive
- Long residence times (~8 hours)
Plasma
- Effective for destruction of long chains
- Produces short chains
- Energy intensive
- Long residence times (~1 hours)
UV-Sulfite
- Effective for destruction of long chains
- Not as effective as other destruction methods
- Long residence times (~8 hours)
Supercritical Water Oxidation
- High destruction efficacy
- Short residence times
- Ability to recover energy
- Inability to treat high salinity feedstocks
- Difficult to manage system corrosion
- Process complexity for managing exothermic reactions
- Significant site infrastructure requirements
Hydrothermal Alkaline Treatment
- High destruction efficacy
- Short residence times
- Treatment of high salinity wastewater
- Low energy requirements with heat recovery
- No toxic byproducts
- No disadvantages
Information is based on currently publically available published data.
Destructive Approach
Advantage
Disadvantage
Incineration
Mature approach
Requires temperatures >1800 °F
Regulatory and liability concerns
Air emissions
Electrochemical Oxidation
Effective for destruction of long chains
Produces short chain PFAS
Energy intensive
Long residence times
Plasma
Effective for destruction of long chains
Produces short chain PFAS
Energy intensive
Long residence times
UV
Effective for destruction of perfluorocarboxylic acids
Difficulty treating perfluorosulfonic acids
Long residence times
Inability to treat turbid water
Diminished efficacy when co-contaminants are present
Supercritical Water Oxidation (SCWO)
High destruction efficacy
Short residence times
Ability to recover energy
Inability to treat high salinity feedstocks
Difficult to manage system corrosion
Process complexity for managing exothermic reactions
Significant site infrastructure requirements
Hydrothermal Alkaline Treatment (HALT)
High destruction efficacy
Short residence times
Treatment of high salinity wastewater
Low energy requirements with heat recovery
No toxic byproducts
Uses common chemical amendments such as caustic soda / lye
Information is based on currently available published data.